Discussion in 'Adapted Lenses' started by ahson, Nov 28, 2011.
As topic...please advise
Well, those are horribly competing metrics. If there was one that was clearly the best, and it was also the most inexpensive, then the other ones wouldn't really exist. The best is not likely to be the most inexpensive; quite the opposite. Canon made one that performs all right, for the FD mount. Nikon made a 180mm f/2.8, because their 200mm lens is f/2.0. If you want "best," Zeiss has one, but you'll be paying 4 times more for it than you would for a Canon FD. Minolta had a Rokkor 200mm, as well as a newer alpha mount 200mm lens. Olympus' telephoto lenses were also weird focal lengths, so you will be looking at a 180mm f/2.8.
The Nikon 180/2.8 is superb. And the value goes up a lot with the older body versions that look like plastic. Nobody really wants the plastic ones, but their optics are great. Even the metal AF-D version is relatively cheap.
There's a Vivitar Series 1 200mm f/3 which is quite nice and inexpensive.
I shouldn't say great but inexpensive because I know some of you must come after me and say there is no such thing.
What I am looking for is a not too expensive lens that will break my wallet, but in a relatively good picture IQ.
I am planning to use the 200mm lens for indoor so a fast lens will be great.
Yeah, the Vivitar Series 1 would definitely fit that description. The last one I almost scooped up in town here was for $175.
Pentax-M 200/f4 is a fantastic performer and cheap, but it's slow.
Pentax-K 200/f2.8 is a fantastic performer and fast, but cheap it ain't...
To be honest it works like this: fast - good - cheap - pick any two
I second the Vivitar. I can't imagine how a 200/F2 would feel on an E-PL1, but this lens helped cause the screws to come loose on my OM adapter! It weighs about 800g. I managed to find one NOS here in the Middle East for around $100. Some handheld images from it are in the sample lens gallery.
Ned, any samples from yours? Didn't know anyone else here had one!
I just noticed you are looking for an indoor lens. Must be a big indoors! The tennis image I linked to above was taken in artificial light in an outdoor stadium.
Separate names with a comma.