For what it's worth, I much prefer the color one.Same photo, but the origional color one was also ran through Exposure 5 "Bleach" effect (below) which gave it a low-color B&W effect.
The computer print judging website, Everypixel.com , scored the original color one at a low "2.9% awesome," and the bleached one popped up a lot to "99.1% awesome." Quite a large difference, and maybe the bleached one seems sharper to it and the difference in its scoring. Don't know how if figures the AI scoring that it does.
View attachment 778899
View attachment 778900