Recommended memory card for the GX7 (Transcend UHS-I cards exhibit weird bugs)

yehuda

Mu-43 Veteran
Joined
Mar 14, 2013
Messages
200
I have 2 32GB Transcend SDHC memory cards.

* See the attached image

The first thing I notices is that formatting the 'red' card (without 300x written on it) in the Panasonic GX7 was VERY slow (roughly 4-5 seconds).
Formatting the 'blue card' (300x card) was much faster (about 2 seconds).

Both cards format in less than a second in the Panasonic G5 with no discernible difference in speed.

The second thing is that from quite a bit of video I took with the GX7 and the 'blue card' (300x) it gave me twice a message about 'the recording will stop due to slow memory card' or something along those lines.

This happened a few minutes after the camera was turned on, not a hot day, not after shooting continuously etc., the memory card was fairly empty and is always formatted in-camera.
I have no idea what's wrong here.

So... is there any GX7 user out there who can recommend me a 32 or 64 GB card that works flawlessly with the GX7?

I must admit I had various brands of cameras and memory cards over the years and never had such weird issues.
While I won't nitpick this, I just want a card that's known to be reliable with the GX7 so I won't lose a special video in the future with that weird recording.

Thanks guys!

Subscribe to see EXIF info for this image (if available)
 

redcapestudio

Mu-43 Rookie
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
24
Location
Los Angeles
Real Name
Robert
I haven't reformatted the card since I purchased it so I can't speak to the speed. I've found that deleting images and video in camera seems fine from a speed stand point.
 

T N Args

Agent Photocateur
Joined
Dec 3, 2013
Messages
3,464
Location
Adelaide, Australia
Real Name
call me Arg
video I took with the GX7 and the 'blue card' (300x) it gave me twice a message about 'the recording will stop due to slow memory card' or something along those lines.
When I had that, the card died within a short while. It was not Transcend.
 

yehuda

Mu-43 Veteran
Joined
Mar 14, 2013
Messages
200
When I had that, the card died within a short while. It was not Transcend.
I've been shooting digital since 2002 and almost all my cards were Trancend. I also used Lexar and SanDisk .
I never had a card die on me and the 300x card I have is relatively new (about 6 months). Since both Transcends are giving me weird problems with he GX7 I wonder if I should get an SDXC card (mine are sdhc) or just switch brands. It's not the money as cards are dirt cheap (30 USD can get me a very fast SDXC 64gb card) but more as to see what solves the problem.

Sent from my W200 using Mu-43 mobile app
 

kstano83

Mu-43 Regular
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
69
Location
Slovakia
Can you guys tell me what the maximum writing speed of a GX7 to an SD card is? I know I should use at least class 4 or 6 for video but I would like to get the max performance from the camera when shooting raw without paying extra money for an unnecessary fast card... Is it even limited? Would I see a writing speed difference between a Sandisc ultra, extreme, extreme plus or extreme pro cards?
 

Wasabi Bob

Mu-43 All-Pro
Joined
Nov 23, 2010
Messages
1,092
Location
New Jersey - United States
1. I've been using the Kingston cards, in several Panasonic cameras, without any problems.
2. SD cards actuality have (3) speeds ratings Read, Write, and Copy. I think it's important to find out what speed they are quoting. In one case I found the speed quoted was the "READ" speed which really wasn't relevant when you are shooting. In general, the WRITE speed is usually the slowest of the three.
3. Another thing I discovered is that while cards may be branded with one brand, what's inside varies. I took two identical (defective) cards apart and discovered that while both contained Samsung memory (many do), both had different (speed rated) memory. Very few manufacturers these days actuality make their own cards.

Since I'm now shooting 4K and 4K Photo mode all my cards are now U3 rated. So far no problems.
 

tkbslc

Super Moderator
Joined
Feb 6, 2015
Messages
7,442
Location
Salt Lake City, UT, USA
Can you guys tell me what the maximum writing speed of a GX7 to an SD card is? I know I should use at least class 4 or 6 for video but I would like to get the max performance from the camera when shooting raw without paying extra money for an unnecessary fast card... Is it even limited? Would I see a writing speed difference between a Sandisc ultra, extreme, extreme plus or extreme pro cards?
Max video bitrate is 28Mbps, which is about 3MB/s so you'll honestly run into speed issues a lot quicker with stills (which are about 20MB in RAW). THat said, sometimes cheaper or slower cards can have trouble with the sustained writes that video requires. So would get a higher end card anyway.

Memory cards are so cheap there is no point in going with a slow card to save literally a few bucks. I'm using a Lexar Professional 150MB/s, a Sony 90MB/s, and a PNY Elite 90MB/s and they all perform very well with the GX7. I mean you spent several hundred dollars on your cameras and at least that much again on your lenses. You really going to compromise on the memory all for $5-10?
 

xvvvz

Mu-43 Regular
Joined
Jul 2, 2013
Messages
85
There was a recent article on one of the photo blogs about the high incidences of fake SD cards on the market these days. I would not be surprised if the one that is flakey is a fake one. Resellers with honest intentions have been duped and don't know they have fakes.
 

kstano83

Mu-43 Regular
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
69
Location
Slovakia
I just found this article http://www.cameramemoryspeed.com/olympus-e-m5-ii/sd-card-comparison/ which says that the average writing speed of a sandisc extreme pro which can easily write at 90MB/s is only up to 40MB/s on an E-M5 II. My point was why to get a card that can write at 90MB/s if a camera can handle only half of that. A card writing up to 40MB/s costs me 10€ while one that is twice fast costs over 30€. And I need two SD cards, which would save me even more money :).
 

kstano83

Mu-43 Regular
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
69
Location
Slovakia
Hmm it says write speed everywhere but I am not sure. The board is not that clear to read overall. But if those are reads, wont writes be even slower?
 

tyrphoto

Mu-43 All-Pro
Joined
May 25, 2014
Messages
1,444
Location
Seoul | NYC
Real Name
ㅇtㅈyㅅr
Many years ago, I used to shoot with whatever card was decently priced. After a couple card failures, I switched over to SanDisk about 10 years ago and have had zero problems since. In any case, SanDisk cards have given me great performance with zero reliability issues. Anyways, these days I use SanDisk Extreme Pro cards exclusively on all of my cameras and would recommend them without hesitation.
 

ripgriffith

Mu-43 Regular
Joined
May 28, 2015
Messages
36
Although I don't shoot video, I have consistently used Silicon Power SDHC 32g cards class 10 for the past few years without failure, currently in a GX7. I haven't timed the formatting speed, but it certainly isn't slow enough to call attention to itself. I haven't timed the read/write speed because unless it is uncommonly slow, it doesn't affect how I shoot, so the only useful information I have to offer is that these cards have never failed on me. That said, I don't know if they are available outside of Russia.
 

Bif

Mu-43 Top Veteran
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
696
Location
San Angelo TX
Real Name
Bruce Foreman
I haven't reformatted the card since I purchased it so I can't speak to the speed. I've found that deleting images and video in camera seems fine from a speed stand point.
You are begging for serious media problems here. Deleting images consistently merely nulls out the first two characters of the filename and results in leaving a cluttered mess of file "fragments" all over the card. Eventually when this catches up with you the result of that is corrupted files and sometimes a very corrupted media card.

Same with only always doing a "quick" format (Panasonic cameras do not offer a "low level" format option, only a "quick" format), all a quick format does is null out the first two characters of each filename in the File Allocation Table, leaving the files themselves on the media and those may often be overwritten in pieces.

If your camera does not offer a choice of format options you need to occasionally do a "low level" format of the media card in a PC reader slot. If on a MAC do not use the Mac formatting command, download and use SD Formatter (free to use).

I do this about every 5 uses of a card.
 

tkbslc

Super Moderator
Joined
Feb 6, 2015
Messages
7,442
Location
Salt Lake City, UT, USA
You are begging for serious media problems here. Deleting images consistently merely nulls out the first two characters of the filename and results in leaving a cluttered mess of file "fragments" all over the card. Eventually when this catches up with you the result of that is corrupted files and sometimes a very corrupted media card.

Same with only always doing a "quick" format (Panasonic cameras do not offer a "low level" format option, only a "quick" format), all a quick format does is null out the first two characters of each filename in the File Allocation Table, leaving the files themselves on the media and those may often be overwritten in pieces.

If your camera does not offer a choice of format options you need to occasionally do a "low level" format of the media card in a PC reader slot. If on a MAC do not use the Mac formatting command, download and use SD Formatter (free to use).

I do this about every 5 uses of a card.
You are inventing risk here, I'm afraid.

You are correct about deletes not zeroing out the bits, but there is absolutely no benefit to doing so on flash media. Flash media is designed to be fragmented. it is not a spinning medium like a hard drive. It does not try to write sequentially to improve access times. It writes to any available free bit and it can access any bit on the flash at the same speed. Frequent full formats only reduces the life of your card by wasting the finite write cycles.

As for corruption, the FAT32 file system can easily handle frequent deletes and rewrites without formatting. It used to be used on PC's, after all, and nobody recommended formatting your HDD every 5 uses of the computer. Don't you think Panasonic would provide a warning if imminent corruption would occur every few photo sessions unless you took the SD card out and formatted in a computer?
 

dornblaser

Mu-43 Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 13, 2012
Messages
3,382
Location
Chicago-area
Real Name
David Dornblaser
Anyways, these days I use SanDisk Extreme Pro cards exclusively on all of my cameras and would recommend them without hesitation.
I also use SanDisk Extreme Pro cards exclusively for the same reason, failure of an SD card of another brand. I do wonder if SD cards are better, more reliable, now than they were 5 - 10 years ago.
 
Links on this page may be to our affiliates. Sales through affiliate links may benefit this site.
Mu-43 is a fan site and not associated with Olympus, Panasonic, or other manufacturers mentioned on this site.
Forum post reactions by Twemoji: https://github.com/twitter/twemoji
Copyright © 2009-2019 Amin Forums, LLC
Top Bottom