Thanks, I hear what you're saying, just went for something off center - kind of following the line of branches.Beautiful shot!
But maybe a tighter crop removing some of the black on the right side (and maybe top and bottom) would make it even better!
Yes a black frame for the moon seems natural, but cropping a little will not hurt this picture, IMHO.
You might even want to hang it on your wall after a crop.
Well, I don't see any branches outside the moon area so maybe you are seeing different things on your monitor.Thanks, I hear what you're saying, just went for something off center - kind of following the line of branches.
I appreciate your viewpoint. Exposing for the highlights did not give the branches any definition aside from the silhouette.Well, I don't see any branches outside the moon area so maybe you are seeing different things on your monitor.
What I see is branches across the moon surface that kind of give a upside down V-shape on about the center of the moon, the rest is black.
Each to his own!
I sympathize and identify with nitpicking.Just to be an annoying nitpicker (my best thing!), I'll mention that these would have to be ENORMOUS branches to cast an actual shadow on the moon! (I think "silhouette" is also another word for shadow). I guess they are more likely to be branches in front of the moon, obscuring a clear shot of it. But it would be very cool if they were shadows, I suppose (right before the aliens blew up our planet with their giant lasers!)
Edit - looking up "silhouette," one definition would fit what we have here, I think - the outline of the actual branches (not a shadow). Phew, glad I cleared that up!
I don't know if a square crop would be better, but since you took this picture with the moon off centre, I think keeping the composition as it is works fine.I appreciate your viewpoint. Exposing for the highlights did not give the branches any definition aside from the silhouette.
Do you think it's better centered as a square crop?
Thanks, yes it is a good one. You are correct, full moons do not show as much detail. Recently it has been a really silver moon, or having a white misty halo effect. I was lucky with this one.
Casting shadows would be especially fitting if you consider that the light of the moon was casting shadows of the branches on you and your camera.I sympathize and identify with nitpicking.
I chose "shadows" since they were out of focus and suggested a shadow effect vs .a silhouette, which I usually associate with greater definition. Literary license, if you will.