1. Reminder: Please use our affiliate links for holiday shopping!

Just randomly testing my SD Cards (very non-scientific)

Discussion in 'Open Discussion' started by KBeezie, Oct 13, 2016.

  1. KBeezie

    KBeezie Mu-43 Top Veteran

    697
    Sep 15, 2012
    Grand Rapids, Mi
    Karl Blessing
    Just a little interesting but non-important SD card testing. Mostly older ones I have.

    Mainly been carrying around the following in my neck strap and camera:
    • Lexar Pro 633x (Class 10 / UHS-I U1) x2
    • Lexar Pro 600x (Class 10 / UHS-I U1)
    • Lexar Platinum II 200x (Class 10 / UHS-I U1)
    Used to have PNYs and Sandisk, but the PNYs kept cracking at the edges particularly around the lock switches, and the Sandisk (mainly the Micro-SD as they were more available locally than just the regular SD) kept giving problems like memory card error or corrupting the data out of the four or so Ultras and Extremes I had (back when they were 30MB/sec and 45MB/sec rated)

    Picked up a Promaster Rugged, normally I wouldn't try a Promaster mainly cuz they just seem like a cheap brand to me, but the 'promise' of being more durable, and having higher write speeds along with a 48 hour replacement guarantee if it fails made me want to least try it.

    So when I got home to test the card in my Lexar Pro USB 3.0 SD reader (a long while back I got it because I figured a dedicated SD reader thru USB 3.0 would give me the best transfer results to the computer, and it does for the most part, "Workflow SR1 SD/UHS-I/USB 3.0 Reader"), and nice enough the promaster does transfer consistently somewhat to the rated speed (the write speed is more accurate than the read)

    My really loose testing is basically computer-only:
    • Each card formatted in my Olympus E-M5 (mk1)
    • Plugged into my Lexar USB 3.0 SD reader plugged directly into a USB 3.0 port
    • A simple "small pattern test" done with CheckFlash 1.16.2
    The last three on the list pretty much never see usage anymore so they just kind of stay home as a 'backup'.

    Yc12h6D.

    Promaster Rugged 16GB UHS-I Class 3 / U3
    Labeled : 99 read, 80 write
    Tested : ~83 read ~79.8 write
    Note : holds both read and write speed consistently within 0.01MB/sec

    Lexar Pro 633x 16GB UHS-I Class 1 / U1 (two copies of this)
    Labeled : 95 read, 10 write (as per lexar's site)

    Copy 1 Tested : ~82.7 read ~20 write
    Note: read held consistent withing 0.05MB/sec, write started at 13, ramped to 20 near 15% dropped down to 18 around 50%

    Second Copy
    Copy 2 Tested : ~83 read ~20.15 write
    Note: holds write speed rather consistently within +/- 0.03MB/sec from start to ~75% dropping to about 17MB/sec to end

    Lexar Pro 600x 16GB UHS-I Class 1 / U1
    Labeled : 90 read, 60 write
    Tested : ~82 read ~45 write
    Note: write starts at 14, quickly jumps to 45 MB/sec climbs about 0.01 per second as the test continues

    Lexar Platinum II 200x SDXC Class 10, UHS-I Class 1/U1 64GB
    Labeled: 30MB/sec read, Write speed unspecified and stated to be "lower"
    Tested : ~44 read ~32 write
    Note: write starts around 35, drops to 20, then back up to a substained 32 (+- 0.1) from 10% onward

    Sandisk Ultra Class 10 UHS-I 32GB
    Labeled 30MB/sec (no separate read/write rating)
    Tested : ~42 read ~12 write
    Note: Used in my little Olympus TG-630 point and shoot.
    Write starts around 11.7, hits 12 around 20% and slowly increases in 0.01 increments to end, peaks around 12.51

    PNY Professional Class 10, no UHS-I rating 16GB
    Labeled : 20Mb/sec ** (assuming for both read/write on the label)
    Tested : ~22 read ~20 write (write starts around 20, increases slowly to about 21 at 25% and holds from there)
    Note: The PNY is mainly a at-home backup, I've had hit/miss issues with PNY, so it just sits around but not as bad as Sandisk Ultras and Extreme SD (mainly microSD in adapters which seems to be what is more commonly sold locally)
    giving me card errors or just ending up corrupted.

    Sandisk Ultra MicroSD 16GB UHS-I Class 1/U1 in PNY MicroSD Adapter
    Labeled Unknown but I beleive it was the same 30MB/sec as the Ultra above purchased around same time
    Tested : ~38.7 read ~13 write
    Note: Starts around 6, jumps to 12.9 by 20% and holds there teetering around 12.98~12.99. the provided sandisk
    adapter kept causing memory read errors in the past.

    Eye-Fi Pro X2 8GB Class 6
    Labeled : Unknown read, Minimum 6MB/sec write speed
    Tested : ~19.5 read ~16.7 write (write holds rather consistent within 0.01 from start to end)
    Note: rates hold rather consistent from start to end,
    the rates are halved when using the Eye-Fi reader (as not all card readers work with the eyefi card) Rarely ever used anymore, too slow for my preference of raw files, and rather have a larger card in the
    point and shoot.

    Comments

    What I found interesting is that my 'newer' Lexar Pro cards are half the write speed of the previous 600x series, and are rated even worse, going from 60MB/sec to 10MB/sec in the newer "professional" model, while having a higher read speed advertised on the new one being the same tested (perhaps the USB 3.0 reader caps around 85). But I guess that may explain their competitive price. On the plus side though, the Lexar never gave me any problems, no memory card errors or corruption, just works.

    Wasn't expecting the Sandisk Ultras to be the worst on the write speeds of what I have, but course they are older. But still performed worse on write than the Eye-Fi card (which from my experience seems to slow down when in camera due to the Wifi capability).

    While I can't seem to find any official numbers, it would seem that the top write speed of my E-M5 isn't going to be any higher than 28~30MB/sec with the fastest card available at the time (ie: Sandisk Extreme Pro 95/90). So anything that can stay consistently over 20 on the write may seem just fine to me either way.

    So yea... my little 'quick' testing out of fun and curiosity might come in handy for someone else. The promaster will probably end up being my main-in-the-camera card, followed by the older 600x Lexar, and if I plan on doing a Timelapse, swap over to the Lexar 64gb, with the other two 16s just in case murphy's law kicks in and I encounter a card error on the screen (Which is why I carry more than two now since the sandisk kept doing that to me).
     
    Last edited: Oct 13, 2016
    • Informative Informative x 2
  2. summerkl

    summerkl Mu-43 Regular

    71
    Jul 26, 2010
    Vancouver
    Kevin L
    Thanks! I was just on a trip and was mildly annoyed by having to wait while my em1 wrote to my card. It's been many years since I purchased a memory card so it crossed my mind to look into the latest advancements.

    Voila! your post saved a lot of internet research.
     
  3. BosseBe

    BosseBe Mu-43 Regular

    109
    Aug 7, 2015
    Stockholm, Sweden
    I did my own unscientific test a couple of weeks ago with my available SD cards (and µ SD).

    GM5 SD card write speed.PNG
    This was done with High burst mode and holding the trigger down until I had enough pictures, then I checked the Date/time of the files after transfer to to the PC.
    So I'm counting the time to save 15 pictures in the highest speed of the camera. (I also tried to calculate the number of Bytes/s for each card, but that is not in the table).
    My conclusion from the tests was that any card with a real write speed of 30MB/s (calculated MB/s) is enough for my generation of cameras. The manual says they are UHS-1 compatible (GM5 and G6) but newer cameras might have UHS-2 support and the higher speed cards will make a difference.

    Sorry about the Swedish, Bild = Picture, Tid = Time and of course sekunder = seconds.

    /Bosse
     
    • Informative Informative x 1
  4. KBeezie

    KBeezie Mu-43 Top Veteran

    697
    Sep 15, 2012
    Grand Rapids, Mi
    Karl Blessing
    Borrowed a classmate's Sandisk Ultra Plus (80MB/sec on the label) and it basically does around 75-80ish for the read, but it's about 15 for the write (guess it still counts as class 10).
     
  5. jyc860923

    jyc860923 Mu-43 Hall of Famer

    Feb 28, 2012
    Shenyang, China
    贾一川
    I have various SanDisks ranging from slow 128g tf to 8gb extreme pro 95MB/s and the extreme pros are really fast, as fast as advertised both read &write, and reliable too. Toshiba cards are not bad too, never was fond of PNY cards or USB drives.
     
  6. KBeezie

    KBeezie Mu-43 Top Veteran

    697
    Sep 15, 2012
    Grand Rapids, Mi
    Karl Blessing
    Can you clarify the write speed (as in done in an actual USB reader, and not guestimate off camera buffer) because what they advertize is just the read speed, though the much more expensive "extreme pro" may differ from the ultra lines.
     
  7. jyc860923

    jyc860923 Mu-43 Hall of Famer

    Feb 28, 2012
    Shenyang, China
    贾一川
    yes, with my kingston mobilelite g4 reader which supports the higher speed uhs2 cards, the uhs1 extremepro 95MB can actually hit 90MB writing performance, just forget those 80 or 45MB cards if you ever burst-shoot raw, the extremepro is worth the price. however the write speed varies hugely with different bodies