any decent PC laptops for photo editing?

so 650

Mu-43 Rookie
Joined
Dec 19, 2010
Messages
10
I know the standard answers are "get a Mac" or "get a good monitor" but given the constraints of needing a laptop and Windows, are there any good options for photography?
 

Danny_Two

Mu-43 Regular
Joined
Oct 30, 2010
Messages
182
Location
London
I had a Toshiba Satellite pro with a tru-brite screen that was pretty good, the screens on top line Sony Vaio's are supposed to be good to.



Not as good as Macs though.
:wink:
 

Alanroseman

Super Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
3,412
Location
New England
Sure,

Buy a PowerBook, get Parallels 6.0 for free with the purchase, install Windoze 7 on it.

The Mac PowerBook will run Windoze 7 faster and more efficiently than almost any low cost windoze laptop, and you'll have the beauty, simplicity and power of Mac OS X to run lightroom, or Aperture 3 from Apple.

Buy the way, Aperture 3 when purchased via the new OSX App store costs only $79.

Many of my clients need Windows 7 for perhaps one reason, maybe running Active X in a browser for example. In those cases, it's Parallels and Windoze on the Mac.

No powering down to boot in either OS. They run simultaneously, and issue free. With version 6 you can easily share even your home folder, as well as seeing the desktop icons for both platforms.

Cheers, Alan
 

~tc~

Mu-43 Hall of Famer
Joined
Oct 22, 2010
Messages
2,494
Location
Houston, TX
Any reason you must have a laptop?

Desktop is much better bang for the buck. I just bought a top of the line intel core i7 "Sandy Bridge" with 1TB HDD and 12 GB RAM, built in card reader -all the goodies - with a 27" monitor for $1600. If there are any laptops that approach this level of performance, they will probably cost twice that, and obviously have a smaller screen
 

Alanroseman

Super Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
3,412
Location
New England
I'd agree. A desktop offers much more bang for the buck.

But a laptop offers a portable studio... and if you're highly mobile, it's almost a must.
 

Alanroseman

Super Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
3,412
Location
New England
One more thing if I may.

As I'm in this business let me add.

Buying a computer is not unlike the purchase of an automobile.

If you haven't made a determination of what your "spend" limit is when buying a car, you wouldn't know wether to start at the Mercedes dealership, or the Chevy dealership.

Same with a computer.

1.Choose an amount that would make you "comfortable" to part with.
2. List the primary use of the machine. Word Processing, graphics, web & comm etc.
4. Examine wether mobility is worth more to you than speed (processing power)
3. Shop at THAT price point only. There are lots of choices out there, lots.

Pick a number, then try to get the biggest bang for your buck.
 

pdh

Mu-43 Top Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
598
I do find it odd that when the question is "Recommend me a laptop that isn't a Mac", the initial responses are "buy a Mac or a desktop" ...

I can't say exactly which brand or model to buy, and it's not clear how much battery time you need, but as I'm considering replacing my (adequate but slow) laptop, it's become fairly clear what the basic specs are for me - lots of RAM (4GB or more), a nice big HDD (320GB, preferably 500GB), and modern quick processor (Intel i5 or i7, although I don't know which AMD chips are equivalently good);; screen technology is a bit of a minefield, you'll need to Google for more info ...

fwiw, a friend of mine (a very fine professional artist and photographer, who uses PS constantly) recently got a refurb Packard Bell from PCWorld, and she's very very happy with it ... so quality isn't necessarily the preserve of top end brands

hope this is of some help

EDIT:

and also, what Alan Roseman said!
 

shoturtle

 
Joined
Oct 15, 2010
Messages
823
macbook or macbook pro. Or any good editing software with allot of memory. editing is a memory hog, upgrade to 4gb or 8gb of ram
 

~tc~

Mu-43 Hall of Famer
Joined
Oct 22, 2010
Messages
2,494
Location
Houston, TX
I do find it odd that when the question is "Recommend me a laptop that isn't a Mac", the initial responses are "buy a Mac or a desktop" ...
True. I can't speak for the others, but I have bought laptops in the past because they were "sexy" and I thought I valued portability more than I actually used it.

I have never had a laptop last more than a couple years before breaking outright or becoming outdated. Mostly because the cost level forced me to buy less processor, HDD, etc than you would get for the same priced desktop. By comparison, my last desktop that I just replaced lasted 10 years with only a HDD upgrade (a much more reasonable option than on a laptop BTW) IMHO because I bought the second fastest thing out there 2.8 GHz HT when top of the line was 3.2. I did the same thing this time, and I hope it turns out similarly.

Moore's Law can be a b!+@h ...

So, to the OP, I would ask, really, how often are you going to do hardcore image processing on the road? Would something like an iPad to do "light" image processing and uploading to facebook, etc be a better solution?
 

so 650

Mu-43 Rookie
Joined
Dec 19, 2010
Messages
10
Thank you all. I will try to clarify my needs, and welcome your continuing suggestions.

I use my home computer for numerous tasks, the only one of which that it reasonably hardware demanding (particularly with respect to screen quality, which is what I meant to get at in the initial post) is photo processing/editing.

It's not actually the portability that I desire, but space savings and the ability to get the thing off my valuable desk real estate to use the desk otherwise. Perhaps I could achieve the same effect with a compact monitor appropriately arranged (and an easily flung away wireless keyboard). Depending on the ease of shoving aside the monitor, that sounds pretty good to me.

Fire away!

(and thanks again)
 

lenshoarder

Mu-43 All-Pro
Joined
Nov 7, 2010
Messages
1,324
Buy a PowerBook, get Parallels 6.0 for free with the purchase, install Windoze 7 on it.
They haven't made PowerBooks in years. You're thinking about MacBook Pros.

Anyways, being a MacBook Pro and a Sony Z owner. Give the Mac to the kids and get a real machine.

OP, you want a Sony Z. It comes with an i5 or an i7 CPU. Upto quad RAID SSDs for 600MB/sec disk access, yes it supports 4 drives builtin. It even has a 1920x1080p screen. This all comes in a 13" 3lb package. You can even get a builtin blu-ray burner. It's the perfect, portable photo processing monster machine that you can take anywhere. Oh yeah, I forgot to say it comes with a nVidia GT330 dedicated GPU you can use to accelerate Photoshop.
 

stratokaster

Mu-43 All-Pro
Joined
Jan 4, 2011
Messages
1,502
Location
Dublin, IE
Real Name
Pavel
Anyways, being a MacBook Pro and a Sony Z owner. Give the Mac to the kids and get a real machine.

OP, you want a Sony Z. It comes with an i5 or an i7 CPU. Upto quad RAID SSDs for 600MB/sec disk access, yes it supports 4 drives builtin. It even has a 1920x1080p screen. This all comes in a 13" 3lb package. You can even get a builtin blu-ray burner. It's the perfect, portable photo processing monster machine that you can take anywhere.
That's true. VAIO Z also has one of the best screens around - it is capable of reproducing 100% of NTSC color gamut.
 

usayit

Mu-43 Hall of Famer
Joined
Jul 2, 2010
Messages
2,964
Location
Some call it the arm pit of NYC.
I'm a Mac guy but I have a respect for Lenovo laptops (work uses them). I didn't see a budget specified but I would probably get this one if a Windows Laptop was a requirement.

Lenovo W701DS (or W701)

http://www.lenovo.com/shop/americas/content/pdf/notebooks/ThinkPad/W-Series/W701-W701ds_datasheet.pdf

for the following primary reasons.

0) spec'd like one of their high end laptops plus
1) Dual Screen on the W701DS
2) Internal RAID controller with two drive bays
3) Pantone Screen Calibration
4) Builtin Wacom tablet digitizer

Its Lenovo's laptop spec'd specifically for graphic artists
 

flash

Mu-43 Hall of Famer
Joined
Apr 29, 2010
Messages
2,004
Location
1 hour from Sydney Australia.
Real Name
Gordon
While the current Macbook Pros are an improvement, their screens (currently around 72% of aRGB) are far from the best available. There's the Lenovo mentioned above. At a lesser cost is the top of the line Sony FW series that does 100% aRGB or the HP's with the "dream color" LCD panels, which are also close to 100% aRGB. Both are LED backlit which gives a wider gamut and improvement in viewing angles. Currently none of these screens, including the Sony, HP or Macbook Pros use IPS panels, so while the gamut is great, top to bottom viewing angles are not as good as they would be in an IPS panel. Currently as far as I know the only laptops that do have IPS panels are some of the more expensive tabletPCs from Fijitsu, Lenovo and HP. FWIW the iPad also has an IPS screen.

Currently I use a Sony (older model) with this 3LED technology and it's simply superb. I don't move up and down much and horizontal viewing angles are very good. While my Eizo desktop monitors are better I hardly ever bother to hook them up, good enough is the Sony display.

Gordon
 

squeegee

Mu-43 Veteran
Joined
Jan 26, 2010
Messages
403
If photo editing is what you have in mind...

I believe macbooks can only display about 75% of the NTSC colour gamut. This is about average for laptops.

If you want to splurg... look at the Lenovo thinkpad w700 series, they can display 100% of the ntsc colour gamut. To the best of my knowledge that laptops display will kick butt on most average home monitors too.

http://www.lenovo.com/shop/americas/content/pdf/notebooks/ThinkPad/W-Series/W701-W701ds_datasheet.pdf

As for the comment "Buying a computer is not unlike the purchase of an automobile. If you haven't made a determination of what your "spend" limit is when buying a car, you wouldn't know wether to start at the Mercedes dealership, or the Chevy dealership. "

I find sales people who make those type of comments totally absurd. The first and foremost thing you should always determine is "what you need". Then the second thing you determine is "what is the cheapest thing that suffices your needs". You don't walk into a car dealer saying I can spend $100,000 with out first determining that all you do is drive to the local grocery store to buy milk. You'll end up spending more than you need to and buying the wrong thing - but making the sales person really happy which is why they always ask that stupid question "how much money can I extract from you... errrr I mean, how much money do you want to spend".

You should *never* shop based on how much money you have or want to spend, you should always shop based on what you need.
 

Alanroseman

Super Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
3,412
Location
New England
If photo editing is what you have in mind...



As for the comment "Buying a computer is not unlike the purchase of an automobile. If you haven't made a determination of what your "spend" limit is when buying a car, you wouldn't know wether to start at the Mercedes dealership, or the Chevy dealership. "

I find sales people who make those type of comments totally absurd. The first and foremost thing you should always determine is "what you need". Then the second thing you determine is "what is the cheapest thing that suffices your needs". You don't walk into a car dealer saying I can spend $100,000 with out first determining that all you do is drive to the local grocery store to buy milk. You'll end up spending more than you need to and buying the wrong thing - but making the sales person really happy which is why they always ask that stupid question "how much money can I extract from you... errrr I mean, how much money do you want to spend".

You should *never* shop based on how much money you have or want to spend, you should always shop based on what you need.
Let me make the crystal clear for you.

When you set your "spend" limit you do not share it with sales people, wether considering the purchase of an automobile, a refrigerator or a sailboat, a computer, or a home. Your spend limit is pre determined based on your personal finances, after discussion with your significant other perhaps, or your bookkeeper..

Making any large purchase without knowing beforehand what you can afford to commit to that purchase leaves one in a very weak position. As one is then susceptible to a "reach" financially.

You should always know going in exactly what your financial limit / commitment is to that particular purchase.

I don't believe I mentioned walking in to a computer store and declaring "I have $2200. to spend!
 

Pelao

Mu-43 Top Veteran
Joined
Feb 3, 2010
Messages
959
Location
Ontario, Canada
Hi

I prefer to work with a Mac computer and highly recommend it as a choice for most tasks. This is based on years of running both OSs in a commercial environment.

But there are plenty of PC laptops that have the horsepower (processor, RAM capacity and good graphics chip) to edit photographs. Any one that exceeds the minimum requirements of your chosen software, and that comes from a reliable vendor, can handle the task. There is lots of choice.

The real question is the screen. For what it's worth, my view is to not try and find a laptop screen (Mac or WIN) for serious editing, especially for print output. Get a good, solid laptop (if it's a laptop you prefer) and get a great screen as your main editing space - and keep it calibrated. The screen will likely still be running when your laptop needs to be replaced.

My personal preference is a small and light (yet powerful) laptop for general stuff, and a maxed out desktop for my photography.

Hope this helps.
 

naturecloseups

Mu-43 Regular
Joined
Jun 10, 2010
Messages
93
I would recommend the HP EliteBook 8740w laptop with Dreamcolor 2 screen, capable of displaying 1+ billion colors. I use one myself with core i7 + 8GB RAM and I don't think it could get any better with present technology.
 
Links on this page may be to our affiliates. Sales through affiliate links may benefit this site.
Mu-43 is a fan site and not associated with Olympus, Panasonic, or other manufacturers mentioned on this site.
Forum post reactions by Twemoji: https://github.com/twitter/twemoji
Copyright © 2009-2019 Amin Forums, LLC
Top Bottom