Well done, folks, congratulations. I asked for creativity and I got it. Very well done!
A couple of you went in the direction I had intended at the time I shot the image. Some of you went in other directions entirely. All of them were lots of fun to look at, judging not so much. My sympathies lie in the direction of the frame I have included below the rankings. If I were to choose on this basis alone, the three finalists would be relic #1 (3), BosseBe #1 (2) and WhidbeyLVR #2 (W). But, what about creativity? Then the three finalists would be betamax (3), Zeus1 #2, RichardC #1 (W). And then there were the HDR-ish entries. The three finalists would be rpatodia #1 (3), WhidbeyLVR #1 (2) and Rob Rider #2 (W). So, what to do with so many winners? Choose arbitrarily, that’s what.
Honorable mention: @ivanbae07 - a fine debut, indeed.
Second runner-up: @Rob Rider #2. Excellent work on lifting shadows and balancing exposures.
First runner-up: @WhidbeyLVR #2. The chiaroscuro sure works for me!
Winner: @RichardC #1. Creative use of the original! Everybody should look at it again and particularly note the shadow of the window frame imitating the lighting of the “photograph”. Tres cool!
The evening's activity was to photograph something, anything in the bowl made by my daughter-in-law. The challenge image was the last frame I shot in the dialing-in process. Looking carefully at it, I identified a poison pill that was not evident to me simply looking at the arrangement in the dim light. The next frame was my keeper.
Subscribe to see EXIF info for this image (if available)
Thank you @Hendrik - it was a good composition to start with. @WhidbeyLVR 's image processing is a tough act to follow with really well saturated colours and a very clean image.
I've studied quite a lot of composited pictures and watched a few tutorials (I am 'tutorial man' since March). The consensus is that they tend to be more believable if you have something to tie your various elements together, hence the shadows. If I did it again, perhaps a coffee mat or another photo covering a corner of the polaroid frame would also be worth a try?
Talking of tutorials - this week's has been 'Photoshop for designers: Textures' by Nigel French on Lynda/Linkedin.
I'll dig up a picture for the next challenge shortly.