Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian Mosley
Interesting move by MR to support the illegal hacking of a Panasonic product... I wonder if dpreview will be so brave?
|
I don't know where MR is hosting his site, but reverse engineering and firmware modifications are legal in Europe, and may be legal in the US[1] as well under the fair use doctrine, as long as the mod is not intended as a circumvention of a legit restriction put in place to protect some interests belonging to IP right holders.
You may lose your warranty in the process, but it doesn't mean you don't have the right to do it. What we're speaking about is a set of patches free of any Panasonic IP, that are to be applied individually by the camera owners over their own legit copy of the firmware.
The only potentially illegal part here is the reverse engineering necessary to build the patches, but many places on earth explicitly allow it. For instance, Europe, and Russia (where many reverse engineers operate from).
Each time someone uses 'illegal' without checking the reality of an existing legal statute or case of precedent, in conjunction with 'hacking', the industry wins in seeding in the minds of ordinary persons that tempering with software is crime. And it's completely wrong. Besides, a kitty dies somewhere.
[1] I'm not qualified enough in the arcane of common law.